The Well-Rounded Permaculturist
by Michael Pilarski, Friends of the Trees Society
So what is permaculture? What makes it different from: organic gardening? organic farming? sustainable agriculture? ecological agriculture? bio-dynamic farming? regeneration farming? forest gardening? Holistic Resource Management HRM? ecosystem restoration? sustainability? or natural building?
Permaculture is unique, yet at the same time includes all of the above. Permaculture is the design of sustainable human settlement. One of the most important things about permaculture is that it’s a synthesis of agriculture, ecology, and forestry. Permaculture is inter-disciplinary as will be outlined in this article.
Permaculture doesn’t have a corner on the market when it comes to sustainable design of human settlements, but permaculture is one of the best design systems we have today. The word “permaculture” was first coined in the mid-1970s by Australians’ Bill Mollison and David Holmgren. The first book on permaculture, “Permaculture One”, was published in 1978. Today there are hundreds of books. The first permaculture design course was held in 1980. Since then tens of thousands of people have gone through design courses in countries around the world. Millions of people have been influenced by permaculture. In spite of this, permaculture remains relatively unknown in most places. The need for sustainable human settlement and local food production is growing fast. The world needs permaculture.
Let’s look at some things a well-rounded permaculturist has to know.
1. A permaculturist has to know food production. How to produce abundant harvests with low external inputs at both the garden scale and farm scale. A good permaculturist should be able to beat (or at least equal) the yields of the best farmers and gardeners in their neighborhood. And at the same time they should be able to do it sustainably, and, in fact, improve their soils and yields over time, while reducing costs.
The well-rounded permaculturist should know the full range of fruits, vegetables, and crops that can be grown in their region. They should be walking plant encyclopedias. Some permaculturists become fluent in the crops and flora of multiple climates. The extreme example is a person who has a good working knowledge of plants useful to humans from the Arctic circle to the equator. This obviously takes decades of study and travel to accomplish. “Economic botanists” are the university-trained professionals who make this their life career. So, in a sense, well-rounded permaculturists are economic botanists. A permaculturist should know the common crops and useful plants of their neighborhood and region. They would also be interested in plants from those parts of the planet with analogous climates/regions. A well-rounded permaculturists will know the native flora of their specific eco-region, e.g. Maritime Pacific Northwest, Great Basin, Intermountain Pacific, Northern Great Plains, Hawaiian Islands, etc.
2. A permaculturist also has to know how to restore ecosystems and how to stop human-accelerated erosion. They should understand native plant restoration, the restoration of native flora and fauna – plants and animals, forests, waterways, streams, rivers, and aquifers. They will understand how to restore ecosystem functions, how to fix up the damage which humans have caused and help nature get back to a state of exuberant health.
3. A well-rounded permaculturist should understand a lot about traditional agriculture and hunter-gatherer cultures, particularly the ethnobotany and ethnoecology of the native people of their region. What were the native foods, medicinal plants, fiber plants, etc.? How did indigenous people manage the game, fish and plant resources of their area? A large part of permaculture knowledge is based on traditional systems from around the world.
These three above traits combined give permaculturists a unique perspective on food production. There are good farmers and gardeners wherever you go. There are good restorationists. There still are some indigenous people practicing their traditional ways. But seldom do members of these three groups know each other’s skills. The permaculturist strives to integrate the knowledge of all three and create systems which are productive, restorative (benefit the ecosystems) and rely a lot on native plants and biota.
Permaculture doesn’t create uniform landscapes. It is the opposite of monoculture and could be called “diversiculture”. Areas close to most dwellings include intensive vegetable gardens, but as one goes further out from the dwellings the landscape becomes more wild and self-managed. Areas that look wild can actually be very productive. Permaculture is based on ecology. Working with nature rather than working against nature. When the Spaniards first came to Guatemala the Mayan home forest gardens established and maintained by the indigenous Maya could contain as many as 200 crop species and be very productive. But they looked so wild that the Spanish did not even recognize them as agriculture. That is the sine qua non of permaculture. To have a system that looks wild and takes care of itself, yet meets the needs of the people. Besides permaculture I only know of two systems which blend these three disciplines together (agriculture, restoration ecology and indigenous knowledge). These two systems are “Analog Forestry” developed in Sri Lanka by Ranil Senanayake and “Rainforestation” developed in The Philippines.
Permaculture encompasses the design of urban yards, suburbs, farmland, rangeland, forests, as well as houses, businesses, intentional communities, eco-villages, islands and whole regions.
A well-rounded permaculturist has to know natural building materials and building design for climate. Passive solar design, energy efficiency, local materials, sustainability. Building materials should be non-toxic during manufacture, use and when decommissioned. He/she should know how plants interact with the building and how to blend outdoor and indoor living spaces, with the aim of cost efficient, comfortable, affordable housing.
The well-rounded permaculturist should know energy systems and technologies.
Well-rounded permaculturists understand how to set up local economic systems, local currencies, barter and exchange systems.
The fully-rounded permaculturist would have a broad understanding of the roles of livestock in agro-ecosystems. What functions do animals have? How can they be beneficial? How do you use animals for their function as well as yield? What do the different kinds of livestock eat? The fully-founded permaculturist will know about natural medicines, breeds adapted to local conditions, grazing systems, fencing, live fences, pasture species’ composition, self-forage crops, practical aspects of raising, etc.
A permaculture student studies and learns how water works in the landscape — how to capture runoff, direct water, deflect flood waters, clean water, store water. What can be done to increase water absorption into the landscape to water the web of life which covers the land and restore springs and natural flows of streams and rivers. The human yield aspect is to study aquaculture, aquatic food chains, species interactions, creating optimal habitat, and fishing management.
Anyone who works with permaculture and other multiple-story agroforestry systems has to study understory/overstory plant relationships. Multiple layers of tall trees, medium trees, tall shrubs, low shrubs, ground covers, tubers, vines, etc. How much shade are plants adapted to? What grows well together? Permaculture is companion planting on a large scale.
Not every region has forests, but where there are forests, then permaculturists study them. What are the native species? Special attention is given to the non-native, weedy species in the region. What are the natural forest successions and which plant species predominate in each succession? What are understory plants, economic species, etc? What are the timber harvesting methods which are sustainable and lead to forest restoration? Where should the network of protected areas be expanded to encompass the full range of native habitats and plant communities in the area? Most places in the world need the active planting of trees and forests to achieve ecosystem health. Forestry is not only the active betterment of current forest acreage, it also includes the active expansion of forest areas into degraded areas, farmland, suburbs and even into the city.
A well-rounded permaculturist will be conversant in the field of mycology – fungi and mushrooms. What are the roles of fungi in the ecosystem? The role of fungi in forests and ecosystems. How to inoculate edible and medicinal mushrooms into the landscape and into the garden. How to encourage and proliferate mycorrhizal fungi which have symbiotic relationships with native plants and our garden vegetables.
Since building soils is one of the chief aims of permaculture, a permaculturist learns how to do this. Most permaculturists study how soils work, soil biology, bacteria, web of life, mycorrhizal fungi, earthworms, nitrogen-fixing azotobacters, soil cation exchange capacity, the role of arthropods, insects, minerals, etc, etc. The main thing is to know how to turn poor and mediocre soils into luscious fertile soils that grow bountiful crops.
Permaculture is based on ecology. How does the ecosystem function? What are all the parts, but more importantly how do the parts interact. How does fire affect ecology? Permaculturists study the role of wildfires in ecoystems.
These are just some of the things a well-rounded permaculturist has to know.
Permaculture involves ethics, principles, design methodologies, observation skills, analytical skills and people skills. Design always involves working with people. Design skills can be applied to social situations as well as to land design.
One person has a hard time to be an expert in all of these fields/topics. A well-rounded permaculturist will specialize in specific fields but also has to gain a general understanding of most of the topics. Permaculturists aren’t born. It takes years and decades of study and practical application to become a well-rounded permaculturalist. But it only takes one course to put people on the path. Practical experience is the most important factor in true learning. Permaculture design, principles and methodology are powerful tools for farmers, gardeners, foresters, social workers, and anyone working for social and ecological change. Permaculture is not something that can be awarded, it is something that has to be earned. It is applying common sense and ecological knowledge to obtaining human sustenance. Permaculturists don’t have a corner on the market. Most permaculturists of the world have never even heard the term. They are quietly going about using their skills to help transform their land, their village, their neighborhood. There are millions of people in every region of the world working towards similar goals and using similar methods. The value in permaculture is that we have devised curricula to help people learn faster how to succeed at creating healthy and productive agro-ecosystems. One permaculture design course sets you on the path. Permaculturists have been searching the world for useful plants, agro-forestry systems, traditional systems, economic botany, sustainable communities, local economies, etc, etc. Through permaculture trainings and books we publicize the knowledge from grass-root experimentation and traditional knowledge from throughout the world and throughout history.
But I’d like to be clear, permaculture is not a religion. True permaculture cannot be dogmatic. There are no cookie-cutter designs. Every permaculture site will look different. Every site and every client is unique. People select what is appropriate and acceptable within their cultural context. Permaculture design methodology can be useful anywhere. However, this does not mean that individual permaculturists are infallible. Like every other profession there are members with lots of practical experience and others that are just beginning and those in between. Permaculturists include the usual wide range of personalities. There are saints, there are jerks, and everything in between. Don’t judge permaculture by your impression of the first person you meet who is espousing it. I encourage everyone who is interested in growing their own food and/or sustainability to look into permaculture. If you are already into permaculture I encourage you to deepen your journey.
Towards a greener and happier world.
Michael Pilarski is a well-rounded permaculturist with specialties in food production, agroforestry, medicinal herbs, forestry, ethnobotany and restoration ecology. He is based in Tonasket, Washington, Interior Pacific Northwest.
Nice article. As permaculturist we do need to know these things but more important we need to implement them!
Love you Michael! keep it up! the fairies are alive and well!
keep it up michael! the fairies are alive and well!
Every word of this kept me hanging and built my enthusiasm, thank you! – from a new permaculture student in PA.
I like Michael Pilarski’s definition of Permaculture as the design of sustainable human settlements. At least this is a working elevator ride definition and is concise and informative and personally very helpful.
His definition of the well-rounded Permaculturist, however, sets the bar so high that I question whether there are more than 10 people in the world who could jump over it. There is something deeply unsettling and minimizing in such sweeping hortatory qualifications, each demanding long study and practice. Mastering fields of study such as agriculture, ecology and forestry and then finding their synthesis, as Pilarski recommends, is a daunting mountain to climb and perhaps misleading. When would one ever be able to take this voluminous knowledge out from the classroom and finally into the design of human settlements?
It seems to me that many Permaculturists bring a particular training and education to the practice, whether they are coming from agriculture, botany, home building, medicine, forestry, or even music. View Permaculture then as a catchall or crucible for most wholesome disciplines. These practices and their practitioners can then find synthesis with Permaculture principles towards something perhaps more unique and specialized. While Permaculture works from the general to the specific, some specialization within it will surely be appreciated. We can’t all know everything. At least I can’t. And, frankly, in the human settlement, are you really going to let just anyone cut your hair or remove your appendix?
Perhaps as important if not more so than expertise in and uberknowledge of all facets of Permaculture, agriculture, ecology, and forestry is simply deepening our understanding of the principles of Permaculture themselves. Holmgrens 12 Principles are a great place to start and the first principle perhaps the most important of all: Observe and interact. By taking time to engage with nature we can design solutions that suit our particular situation. Revelations based on observation will lead to the right tools, the right studies, the right solutions. We can bring not only our Permaculture training to these endeavors, but our entire life experience as well. In this manner Permaculture becomes a mindset, a way of living, an attitude. It changes the way we think about ourselves, the earth, and our relationships with each other and imbues everything we do. Of course, this isn’t necessarily easy as old habits and preconceived ideas tend to grab us all by the scruff of the neck. But, chances are that if we reflect on and practice these principles daily we probably will get better at them. In the same fashion as many of us with similar mindsets practice these principles we can begin to see them influence the overall culture of the larger human settlement.
Philadelphia, PA USA
A trully great article, interesting, motivational, real and above all; inspirational. Thanks Mr. Michael Pilarski, im a 27 year old permaculture enthusiast and devote practitoner in México, i study and practice permaculture everyday as much as i can so one day i can be a well rounded permaculturist, my only motivation is to take care and enjoy the two things i love the most; nature and human kindness. Thanks again for the article.
Michael’s list of criteria for what makes a well-rounded permaculturist, while wide reaching, is a good list and is quite possible if you keep one thing in mind: it’s OK not to know everything. What we have to be is observant and ready to learn!